Why I don't like Blogger.
First of all, these are my personal opinions and I am not trying to force them upon you nor do I claim any of them to be facts.
I don’t think that Blogger is necessarily a bad platform, there are just a few irritations and gripes that I have with it. The first major pain is the overall look of every blog tends to look the same. Blogger has a big user-base which is great, but when a form of design monotony starts to creep into a community, changes should be made. Typographically, Blogger has a bias towards Trebuchet-MS. There’s something about that face I just don’t like. I can’t put my finger on it, but it irritates the life out of me.
Then there’s Georgia. Whilst I appreciate why it’s there, it seems to be used very inappropriately. Used as a display face at relatively small sizes? Really? Surely this design-monopoly goes against the vein of blogging? Isn’t blogging about individuality and self-publication?
Then there’s that top ‘blogger navigation’ bar. That just plain sucks. This leads me onto my next gripe. Blogger tries way to hard to be social. Listen up Google; I thought you were all about the standards? You can pack in all that proprietary following with a Google account business. Unfortunately this following thing seems commonplace. Even Tumblr does this nonsense. I like to know who reads my stuff, but seriously it can’t be that hard to add how many people subscribe via RSS too? Google could use their Analytics knowledge for Blogger.
Bloggers woes are probably created by the poor templates. I say ‘poor’ in haste really as they’re actually very compliant. However standards don’t equal great design without adding in the future-looking stuff. Be a bit bad-ass and write in some font classes that might only work on Macs or Windows. Dare we stipulate Helvetica first over the more compliant Arial?! What’s the worst that can happen? Your site won’t freak and die on your user. I agree that there’s a limit, I mean let’s not go genuinely mental and bring a font like Bello into the mix, chances are it’ll never get seen, but there are cases to be made.
My biggest personal gripe is not directly Blogger related, but with Blogger dominating the blogosphere it’s the biggest perpetrator of this crime. A blog is a form of website that needs to be treated in the way that it was meant to be used. Blogger handles text O.K. but deals with other media pretty badly. After one image it starts to fall apart. Tumblogs were designed with multimedia in mind. Doesn’t the choice make sense? Some things just weren’t intended for a blog. Long live the mini-site!
I’ve been really happy with Tumblr. It keeps me concise and focused on getting my message out without confusing it in translation. If I can’t make my point in one image, I have failed. if I need to write a monster post, I can. If I want to add rhythm, I can insert much shorter snippets and inject a bit of interest with audio, quotes etc. It doesn’t feel like your preparing a contained piece of communication, but the output is the same.
Blogger made me blog. It was a chore.